Sign up | Log in



Home  >>  Daily News  >>  ASEAN ANALYSIS


Asean Affairs   7 February 2014

Myanmar’s Constitutional Review Committee Shies Away from Needed Changes

By Greg Poling, Phuong Nguyen, & Courtney Weatherby

Myanmar’s Constitutional Review Joint Committee, a 109-member parliamentary body tasked with reviewing potential changes to the nation’s 2008 military-drafted charter, issued its preliminary recommendations on January 31. The only significant change that the committee proposed appears to be a greater devolution of authority to states and regions. This meets a key demand of many ethnic groups, but it is just one of several changes needed. Unfortunately, international attention has focused overwhelmingly on just one of them.

The committee advised against modifying Article 59F, which bars individuals from becoming president if their spouses or children hold foreign citizenship, thereby disqualifying opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi. An amended constitution that still bars Aung San Suu Kyi from becoming president will likely mean continued U.S. sanctions on Myanmar. The U.S. Congress on January 17 passed a new spending bill that makes the removal of remaining sanctions conditional on reforms to make the constitution more democratic and progress on various human rights issues. The former is in large part aimed at the opposition leader’s eligibility for president. Members of the U.S. Congress have long been supporters of Aung San Suu Kyi, who dominates the narrative about Myanmar on Capitol Hill. Senator Mitch McConnell last year called the amendment of Article 59 one of three constitutional reform priorities for Naypyidaw.

Parliamentary speaker Shwe Mann, as a declared presidential contender, would benefit most from leaving Article 59F intact. It seems implausible that his Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) could best Aung San Suu Kyi’s National League for Democracy in the 2015 elections, meaning that Shwe Mann’s best chance for the top job is for the opposition leader to remain disqualified. Last October the speaker voiced support for amending the constitution to allow Aung San Suu Kyi to run, but has since hedged. A week before the committee released its report, Shwe Mann said that while he would welcome an Aung San Suu Kyi presidency, amending Article 59 is not the only priority. That statement might be self-serving, but it was not without merits.

Barring citizens from the presidency because of their family members is clearly unfair, but it is not the most pressing amendment needed to Myanmar’s constitution. The committee also proposed no changes to Article 109, which guarantees the military one quarter of all parliamentary seats, or to Article 436, which requires approval from three-quarters of lawmakers to amend the most sensitive parts of the constitution. And the committee recommended keeping a chapter of the constituion that grants immunity to officials of the former military regime who committed crimes while carrying out their duties. Maintaining these clauses that grant the military such wide-ranging special treatment will make it difficult for any future civilian government to pursue comprehensive, rules-based reforms.

The committee also ignored ethnic armed groups’ demands for a federal, rather than unitary, army. If left unaddressed, this issue risks undermining ongoing national ceasefire talks. The committee’s report opted to toe the military’s line, rejecting amendments that would make possible a new army with a more decentralized command structure and greater representation for members of ethnic groups. Myanmar’s constitution stipulates that ethnic armies must stay under the control of the central government’s armed forces, and Commander-in-Chief Min Aung Hlaing last year rejected calls for a federal army. This will be a pill that most ethnic armies, who have spent decades fighting the government, will be unable to swallow.

Considering that 75 of the 109 members of the Constitutional Review Joint Committee are from the ruling Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) or the military, disappointment with its recommendations was not unexpected. The committee’s report is not binding, and it would be premature to see it as a sign of an impending anti-reform drive in Myanmar. But it does signal the reservations of the military and ruling party regarding constitutional amendment.

The next step is for a smaller committee of 31 lawmakers to discuss the report’s findings and make official recommendations to the parliament. They will need to address the report’s most flagrant shortcomings, but without stoking military fears of being marginalized by the reform process. Amending the most pressing chapters, like the inordinately high bar for future amendments or the commitment to a unitary military, are critical to Myanmar’s ongoing reforms and peace efforts. But the committee’s timidity shows that there may be no way forward for the country’s nascent democracy if military leaders come to fear being marginalized in the reform process. This means that not every necessary change to Myanmar’s constitution can be pushed through this year.

Courtesy: This post originally appeared on the Center for Strategic and International Studies, Washington D.C. cogitASIA blog

Reach Southeast Asia!
10- Nations, 560- Million Consumers
And $1 -Trillion Market
We are the Voice of Southeast Asia Media Kit
The only Media Dedicated to Southeast Asia Advertising Rates for Magazine
Online Ad Rates

Comment on this Article. Send them to

Letters that do not contain full contact information cannot be published.
Letters become the property of AseanAffairs and may be republished in any format.
They typically run 150 words or less and may be edited
submit your comment in the box below




1.  Verifier

1. Verifier

For security purposes, we ask that you enter the security code that is shown in the graphic. Please enter the code exactly as it is shown in the graphic.
Your Code
Enter Code

Today's  Stories    February 7, 2014 Subsribe Now !
• Event Calendar 2014/15 Subcribe: Asean Affairs Global Magazine
• Yingluck admits rice subsidies need revamp if re-introduceddeportation order
• Rupiah trading at 12,197 per dollar
Research Reports
on Thailand 2007-2008

• Textiles and Garments Industry
• Coffee industry
• Leather and footwear industry
• Shrimp industry

• Govt issues Rp 1.57t project-based sukuk
• Wood exports upward bound 
Asean Analysis                    7 February  2014 Advertise Your Brand
• Asean Analysis-February 7, 2014
Thai Democracy Faces Continuing Hurdles in the Wake of Elections
• Asean Analysis-February 7, 2014
China becomes largest investor in Laos
Asean Stock Watch     7 February 2014
• Asean Stock Watch-February 7, 2014
• Asean Analysis-February 7, 2014
Myanmar’s Constitutional Review Committee Shies Away from Needed Changes

The Biweekly Update
• The Biweekly Update  February 7, 2014

ASEAN NEWS UPDATES      Updated: 04 January 2011

 • Women Shariah scholars see gender gap closing
• Bank Indonesia may hold key rate as inflation hits 7 percent
• Bursa Malaysia to revamp business rules
• Private property prices hit new high in Singapore • Bangkok moves on mass transport
• Thai retailers are upbeat
• Rice exports likely to decline • Vietnamese PM projects 10-year socioeconomic plan


This year in Thailand-what next?

AseanAffairs   04 January 2011
By David Swartzentruber      

It is commonplace in journalism to write two types of articles at the transition point between the year that has passed and the New Year. As this writer qualifies as an “old hand” in observing Thailand with a track record dating back 14 years, it is time take a shot at what may unfold in Thailand in 2011.

The first issue that can’t be answered is the health of Thailand’s beloved King Bhumibol, who is now 83 years old. He is the world's longest reigning monarch, but elaborate birthday celebrations in December failed to mask concern over his health. More


Home | About Us | Contact Us | Special Feature | Features | News | Magazine | Events | TV | Press Release | Advertise With us

Our Products | Work with us | Terms of Use | Site Map | Privacy Policy | Refund Policy | Shipping/Delivery Policy | DISCLAIMER |

Version 5.0
Copyright © 2007-2015 TIME INTERNATIONAL MANAGEMENT ENTERPRISES CO., LTD. All rights reserved.
Bangkok, Thailand