Sign up | Log in



Home  >>  Daily News  >>  ASEAN ANALYSIS


                                                                                                                           Asean Affairs August 19, 2013  

The Growing Problem of Land Conflicts in Indonesia

Land and resource conflicts are an increasing source of violence in Indonesia, and a looming showdown in Sumatra shows why. The dispute in Mesuji, Lampung province is over an industrial tree plantation, but it could just as easily be a mine or a palm oil estate. Whatever the cause of the initial dispute—in this case a land-grab that goes back decades—the conflict has become infinitely more complex over the last two years as political and economic stakes have increased.

Several factors have come into play:

• Land values have risen in the area because of the demand for bio-fuels, and many Jakarta-based actors are suddenly interested in championing claims against the company in the hope of getting access to large chunks of land in return.

• The attraction of claiming land in the name of indigenous rights—even before the May 2013 ruling from the Constitutional Court that “indigenous forests” could no longer be considered state land—has led to the creation of several competing indigenous councils all purporting to speak on behalf of local communities. At least one of these councils made membership available for a fee to migrants from outside the area.

• A national politician attracted by the career of the late Venezuelan president Hugo Chavez and preaching radical socialism as an antidote to neo-liberalism believes he can create a political base by encouraging occupation of plantation land by poor farmers, not only in Lampung but across the country.

• Local police turned a blind eye to the organized in-migration of thousands of new settlers, despite the violation of numerous laws. Perhaps not coincidentally, one of the groups organizing the newcomers itself has close ties to the police.

• By the time thousands of new arrivals were in place, their numbers had reached the point where they were of interest to politicians needing to secure votes for local elections and of local merchants seeking custom.

All of this means that the story of a once-protected forest area-turned-plantation called Register 45 in Mesuji—described in detail in a new report released on August 13 by the Jakarta-based Institute for Policy Analysis of Conflict (IPAC)—is no simple story of poor/good farmers against rich/bad company. Instead it is one of multiple and competing groups of farmers, legitimate and spurious claims, overlapping and contradictory laws, different parts of the government speaking with different voices, new actors coming into the picture, and constantly changing goalposts.

The conflict, however, could be reaching a showdown, as in late July the provincial government, working on instructions from the Coordinating Ministry for Political, Security, and Legal Affairs, sent 400 police and soldiers to Register 45 to warn all squatters to leave or face forcible eviction as soon as the August 8-9 Idul Fitri holidays were over. Since many have no home to go back to, the result could be resistance and bloodshed.

The question is how conflicts like Mesuji can be resolved when few trust the courts or police and the central government invariably dithers until violence erupts. Even the basic task of distinguishing between genuine and illegitimate claims is a hugely complex undertaking when corruption makes all data suspect. In this case, the best of a series of bad options is to develop a workable relocation plan for settlers who arrived from late 2011 onwards; investigate and prosecute the organizers behind the land clearing and sales; and have an independent commission review the grievances against the company. Implementing recommendations from a 2012 government fact-finding report would be a good place to start.

Perhaps more important for the future is to back the “one map movement” developed by the President’s Unit for Control and Monitoring Development (Unit Kerja Presiden Bidang Pengawasan dan Pengendalian Pembangunan, UKP4) to improve spatial planning before future land concessions are authorized. The initiative tries to ensure that a consultative mapping project takes place so that everyone is agreed where community land begins and ends. But in a place like Indonesia, where many different claims to the same land can all be legal, depending on what law is used, prevention of these disputes is not going to be easy.

Ms. Sidney Jones is director of the Institute for Policy Analysis of Conflict (IPAC). She can be reached at

Courtesy: This post originally appeared on the Center for Strategic and International Studies, Washington D.C. cogitASIA blog

Reach Southeast Asia!
10- Nations, 560- Million Consumers
And $1 -Trillion Market
We are the Voice of Southeast Asia Media Kit
The only Media Dedicated to Southeast Asia Advertising Rates for Magazine
Online Ad Rates

Comment on this Article. Send them to

Letters that do not contain full contact information cannot be published.
Letters become the property of AseanAffairs and may be republished in any format.
They typically run 150 words or less and may be edited
submit your comment in the box below

Today's  Stories    19  August 2013 Subsribe Now !
• ASEAN EXCHANGES CEOs MEET TO DISCUSS STRATEGIES FOR 2014 Subcribe: Asean Affairs Global Magazine
• ASEAN appoints AKP Mochtan from Indonesia as Deputy SecGen for Community and Corporate Affairs Asean Affairs Premium
• 'United Asean will try to convince China on sea code of conduct'
Research Reports
on Thailand 2007-2008

•Textiles and Garments Industry

•Coffee industry

•Leather and footwear industry

•Shrimp industry

• Vietnam has largest online population in ASEAN
• Bank card count reached 60.15m by end of June: SBV
• Myanmar government ‘pivotal’ in constitutional change
• Philippine ferry death toll climbs to 38, as oil leaks
Asean Analysis           19 August 2013 Advertise Your Brand
• Asean Analysis- August 19, 2013: The Growing Problem of Land Conflicts in Indonesia
• Asean Weekly:The Biweekly Update 9 August 2013
Asean Stock Watch     16 August  2013
• Asean Stock Watch-August 16, 2013 

ASEAN NEWS UPDATES      Updated: 04 January 2011

 • Women Shariah scholars see gender gap closing
• Bank Indonesia may hold key rate as inflation hits 7 percent
• Bursa Malaysia to revamp business rules
• Private property prices hit new high in Singapore • Bangkok moves on mass transport
• Thai retailers are upbeat
• Rice exports likely to decline • Vietnamese PM projects 10-year socioeconomic plan


This year in Thailand-what next?

AseanAffairs   04 January 2011
By David Swartzentruber      

It is commonplace in journalism to write two types of articles at the transition point between the year that has passed and the New Year. As this writer qualifies as an “old hand” in observing Thailand with a track record dating back 14 years, it is time take a shot at what may unfold in Thailand in 2011.

The first issue that can’t be answered is the health of Thailand’s beloved King Bhumibol, who is now 83 years old. He is the world's longest reigning monarch, but elaborate birthday celebrations in December failed to mask concern over his health. More






1.  Verifier

1. Verifier

For security purposes, we ask that you enter the security code that is shown in the graphic. Please enter the code exactly as it is shown in the graphic.
Your Code
Enter Code

Home | About Us | Contact Us | Special Feature | Features | News | Magazine | Events | TV | Press Release | Advertise With us

| Terms of Use | Site Map | Privacy Policy  | DISCLAIMER |

Version 5.0
Copyright © 2006-2017 TIME INTERNATIONAL MANAGEMENT ENTERPRISES CO., LTD. All rights reserved.
Bangkok, Thailand